If you slip on black ice at a Burlington County business, the property owner may be liable if it failed to address a hazard it knew or should have known about. Black ice is a thin, nearly invisible layer of ice that can form on pavement, especially in parking lots, sidewalks, shaded entrances and areas with poor drainage.
When does notice establish liability
In many New Jersey premises liability claims, you must establish that the owner knew or should have known about the hazard. Actual notice means the owner knew about it. Constructive notice exists when the condition existed long enough that a reasonably diligent owner should have discovered it.
Recurring icy conditions, drainage problems, previous complaints and poor maintenance may help establish notice. Black ice alone does not automatically establish liability in a New Jersey snow and ice accident claim. New Jersey courts also distinguish between commercial and residential owners when determining responsibility for abutting public sidewalks. A New Jersey Supreme Court case involving a black-ice fall on an abutting public sidewalk addresses this distinction.
How do storm rules affect claims
Absent unusual circumstances, commercial property owners generally do not have to remove snow and ice while a storm continues. Under Pareja v. Princeton International Properties (2021), their duty to address accumulated snow and ice usually begins within a reasonable time after the storm ends.
Two exceptions may apply: a commercial property owner’s actions create unusual circumstances that increase the danger, or a hazardous condition existed before the storm. For example, unresolved ice from an earlier storm may create a pre-existing risk.
In Gallardo v. Walmart (2026), the New Jersey Supreme Court held that applying salt to minimal snow accumulation during an ongoing storm did not, by itself, amount to unusual circumstances under the first exception. Whether a property owner’s actions rise to that level still depends on the specific facts of each situation.
What evidence supports your case
Evidence that may support a black ice claim includes:
- Photographs of the icy area and surrounding conditions.
- Weather records showing when freezing occurred.
- Maintenance records showing how the owner addressed winter hazards.
- Surveillance footage and witness statements describing conditions before and after the fall.
- Previous complaints about recurring ice in the same location.
Records of repeated ice formation may help show that the owner should have anticipated the hazard. Preserve evidence as soon as possible.
Protecting your rights after a fall
Seek medical attention and report the incident to the owner or manager. Record where and when the fall occurred. If you were injured on icy property in Burlington County, the evidence and timing of the storm may help determine your legal options.

